The Garden of Eden for Bonefish has a Name – Alphonse Island

Seychelles February 2019

Alphonse is the ultimate hotspot for any fly fisherman who wants to catch bonefish in large numbers. After arriving at Mahe we transferred to another hangar and continued our journey in a Cessna. The flight to Alphonse Island took another 45 minutes. The island boasts a good resort with a self-sufficiency concept (it has its own solar energy supply, cattle and pig breeding, market gardening and fruit plantation etc.) and is similar to the one on Denis Island. The resort has about 30 beach bungalows and a couple of beach suites with bicycles available for the guests.

Breakfast was at 6 a.m. and at 7 o’clock we all boarded a catamaran which took us over to St. Francois, the crossing taking about 45 minutes. This island is blessed with flats containing schools of up to several hundred bonefish. We began our first day targeting these bones and by an hour and three quarters we had all caught 20 bonefish each – what a start.

To make sure things didn’t get “boring” we then steamed out to outer reef on our skiff for some GT fishing. We tried our luck with numerous blind casts along the underwater structures and the reef itself using so-called popper flies. Then two GTs appeared from nowhere, the first a “smaller” specimen” about 110 cm long and then a genuine trophy fish of about 130 cm in length, and they both went straight for the lure. The big GT literally inhaled the popper and took off at high speed into deeper water – hook-up! After a couple of runs it gradually began to tire and came slowly but surely to the boat. Everything was going very well indeed. Our guide was getting prepared to bring the fish on board when the moment came which all of us anglers fear. The line was tight and the fish about 10 meters under the boat when we lost contact. At first we thought the 100 lb. leader or the fly line had snapped. But no, everything was retrieved intact, including the popper – the hook had pulled…

Nobody had made a mistake and after a long discussion we came to the conclusion that the “smaller” GT that had been following the action for the whole time also tried to take the popper fly which led to the hook pulling. This is only a guess but our guides said it had happened before – bad luck and particularly annoying with a trophy fish. None of us is ever likely to forget that strike.

The remaining days followed the same pattern. We caught numerous bonefish in the flats. On the outer reef we were able to boat a couple of Bluefin trevallies and other reef predators. Unfortunately we are unable to hook any more GTs. It’s not that easy targeting GTs from a skiff. When you do get a bite after hundreds of casts it usually comes from nowhere and everything happens very, very quickly. You need a fish that grabs the popper and takes off in the other direction. It is extremely difficult to hook a GT that chases the popper and swims towards to the skiff at full speed. When it has the lure in its mouth it will, in most cases, spit it out again in a fraction of a second – you have to strip your line at a hell of a rate.

Our group which consisted of 12 anglers only caught a couple of GTs during the week we were there. Trigger fish are in abundance but they are very cautious. We got the impression that they had seen plenty of flies in their lifetimes. None were caught that week.

We also saw big milkfish every day. Unfortunately they did not congregate in the desired schools and were thus not really easy to target. Although another angler caught a small permit, our team failed to find any.

Summary: Fly fishermen should visit Alphonse Island under all circumstances, if only for the large numbers of bonefish.

The next challenge is to fish the waters of Astove and Cosmoledo.

Tight Lines Stephan Kreupl, March 2019